People are very well aware of what happened in Uri. Eighteen soldiers. Not a small number by any margin. The terrorists were backed by the Pakistani establishment. With me till now?

I’m from that crop of people who believe that Pakistani artistes should leave India. Most of them have already left and won’t be coming back anytime soon. It’s surprising, I suppose, that someone who likes to call himself a writer (to give his ego a push every now and then) backs such a stand. After all, cricket, music, and films, among  other things, don’t have anything to do with terrorism, right? Pretty much.

I’m all for Pakistanis and Bangladeshis and Afghans and Martians and people from the entire Universe coming to work in India but not at the cost of our national pride. Wait, what’s that? National pride? Half the people I meet are Maharashtrians, Tamilians, Punjabis before they are Indians. But, I believe I’m digressing from the issue I wish to speak about.

People like Sitaram Yechury, Karan Johar, Mahesh Bhatt, Darkha Butt (or is it Barkha Dutt?), Sallu (or is it Lallu? I’m really confused) have spoken about how art and cultural exchange is above terrorism and that we should continue talking to Pakistan. Pahlaj Nihalani also backed this but he’s of no relevance. Nor are three of the five people mentioned but anyway. Understandable. A lot of people seem to agree with them. I too, to a certain extent, agree with them. I mean, if this had been a US-USSR face-off during the Cold War, it would’ve been totally acceptable. But who the fuck are we? India. Haven’t we always shown the world that we are stalwarts of tolerance? I mean, our intent to deal with Pakistan firmly has been as serious as our will of losing to them at the Cricket World Cup. So, a lot of people perhaps thought we should chill the fuck out. Only, we shouldn’t and we don’t seem to be doing that. The Indian Army conducted a cross-border expedition where they showed Pakistan-backed militants our mehmaan-nawaazi. Such was the mehmaan-nawaazi that we were done with them before they entered Indian territory with their darling GPSs and weapons.

But, pray tell me, can this art-and-culture exchange exist at a critical juncture like this? We are locking horns with a notion called ‘Pakistan’. We might be engaged in a state of conventional war with them in the near future. But, do we not owe our soldiers gratitude in some other form apart from monetary help, Facebook posts, Tweets, WhatsApp forwards? Or are we just a bunch of assholes who become patriotic on two particular days in a year and on the days that soldiers are martyred? Where is our patriotism the rest of the time? Where is our love for our soldiers when Pakistan needs to be dragged to the ICJ for violating the Geneva Convention? Let’s be frank. It is a very finicky idea for us, patriotism. Stays with us for a very small period of time.

Pakistani artistes may be as good as gold. Hell, Fawad Khan is made of gold the way girls drool over him! The guy’s a fine actor. Atif Aslam, Ali Zafar, Rahat Fateh Ali Khan. I could go on. Last year, two Indian actors were termed anti-nationals. Shah Rukh Khan’s Dilwale faced the brunt of his remarks, which weren’t all that off the sweet spot. Shah Rukh tweeted against the Peshwar Attack of December 2014. Shah Rukh tweeted against the Uri Attack of 18th September 2016 and backed our Armed Forces on the day of the surgical strike. Amitabh Bachchan and Akshay Kumar were two of the other film stars who commented on the Uri Attacks. But where were the rest? And more importantly, where were the people? We didn’t think twice before condemning Peshawar or Paris but forgot our very own Pathankot. What is wrong with us?! Are we addled?

The Board of Control for Cricket in India has already decided not to play matches against Pakistan. The ICC Champions Trophy, scheduled for 2017, may see a change in schedule. Anurag Thakur, a BJP MP, is the President of the BCCI. Would this have been the stance had the President been a Congress MP? Or an AAP one (laughable as that is)? No. The Opposition and Government are always at loggerheads. Not possible even if roles were reversed, ie: Congress at Centre, BJP in Opposition. But then the chatter began. “What wrong have Pakistani artistes done? Their country is also ravaged by war. Are the artistes terrorists?” A lot of mud-slinging began, courtesy one has-been Bollywood singer who considers it his birthright to open his filthy mouth on every issue. I agree with the fact that Pakistani artistes are not terrorists, they come from a war-zone of a country (if we can call Pakistan one) and that they’ve done no wrong. However, I do consider it weird that not one of them, not Fawad Khan, not Ali Zafar, not Mahira Khan, not Atif Aslam, not Rahat Fateh Ali Khan, not Shafqat Amanat Ali, not one opposed the Uri Attack. After all, our people whole-heartedly supported Pakistan after Peshawar. What stopped all these people who’d earned their bread and butter on our soil to condemn an attack on an Indian Army camp? I sincerely don’t think it was an admission of Pakistan’s involvement in the attack. Their people are in the dark about their establishment’s actions and alliances. A lot of people said that these people weren’t willing to condemn the attack simply because their families would be in danger. Tell me, do we not have ultras in India? Those monkeys who are hardcore radicals in their beliefs regarding religion and nationality? We have our fair share, perhaps a few too many, of those. None of them threatened the famous Indians who condemned the Peshawar attack. They could have, but they didn’t. So what stopped these Pakistanis?

Also, do we not have a moral responsibility to stand by our soldiers? There’s nothing that can be done about Raees and Ae Dil Hai Mushkil‘s release. They had already commenced production before Pathankot and completed production before Uri. Before relations with our padosi had dropped to such a low. No point in banning those films. Fawad and Mahira had valid visas and work permits. Excel, Red Chillies, Fox Star and Dharma couldn’t have seen the attacks coming. The films are ready for release. I am of the opinion that they should release and without any restrictions or violence. Investors will face massive losses if these films are not released. And these investors include a whole bunch of people, not just Karan Johar and Fox. Let them release. Period. But, no Pakistani of any profession can work in India. Why are we just talking about celebrities? Any Pakistani, whatever the nature of their visit to India, should be asked to leave. Even the High Commissioner if needed. Cancel their visas and work permits and send them back. I’ll now back this up. I am a Fauji Brat. My sentimental attachment to the Indian Army is bound to be a factor in what I’ll say but I’m saying it anyway. At this point of time, the quality of weapons and uniforms and rations and living conditions for troops stationed at the LC (Line of Control) is quite poor. This is not confidential information. It is public knowledge. Tomorrow, if there is war, it will come down to these men and so many others to defend our motherland. If their weapons aren’t working, if the rations are terrible, if the uniforms are of no use, they will fall back on something that has a lot to do with the mind: morale. If we say “We are with the soldiers and all but Fawad is hot so he shouldn’t leave”, what will the morale of these soldiers be? Frankly, a large number mayn’t even give a damn about all this and will carry on with their job. Morale plays a major role in war. If this morale is dented, what do we expect our soldiers to do? Should they be as welcoming of Pakistani soldiers as the rest of us are of Pakistani artistes, using the excuse that “They too are simply doing their job”. Will that be acceptable to anyone? No. You’ll be aghast if such a thing happens. Those men have signed up for a highly dangerous job. The least those of us sitting with laptops and smartphones in t-shirts and boxers in the wee hours of morning can do is back them in some way or the other. Getting rid of artistes from across the Radcliffe Line will help raise the morale.

If someone could tell even a single soldier how proud this country is to have a person like them, morale will rise. If our highly-opinionated Bollywood stars can go and spend some time with these brave men (without NDTV, please), morale will rise because, let’s face it, we are very fond of our film stars. If a sportsperson can do the same, that’d be fantastic. Basically, don’t just say you are with the Armed Forces. Do something that makes it seem like you actually are. Write a blog post, a poem, record a video. They ought to know that they aren’t sitting in trenches and bunkers unfit for human inhabitation for a country of 1.25 billion (can we look into that too sometime later?) assholes who don’t give a damn about them. They deserve to know that we genuinely respect them. They deserve to know that it is not only in the event of a natural or manmade calamity that we remember them, those brave men in uniform.

JAI HIND.

Please leave your comments in the section below. Share the post if you liked it. Tell me you disagree with me and we’ll chat about it. Nothing showcases the power of democracy better than people talking about issues, huh? Cheers.

Varun Bhakay’s Writer’s Block (2016)

Advertisements

18 comments

  1. Well written.

    A few things about the artistes both Indian and Pakistani, and the attacks etc, well, those need to be looked at from several angles; especially with the misinformation flying all around, and the convenience with which our celebrities choose to live their lives, choosing to be with someone on one day, and silent another.

    However, this whole goddamned convenient population of India being unable to fathom what the real meaning of patriotism is, is something that’s extremely relevant; starting with our laws not allowing thugs and criminals to run this country and be responsible for diplomatic (or undiplomatic, as it were) parlance.

    It’s easy to condemn one day and support another based on your convenience. This fickle population goes by what they are shown and are swayed by just about anything without having their own thought through general opinion on a set of situations.

    And yes, Darkha’s Butt and other such half-witted journos and news channels need to be told to stay the fuck away from strategic sites and front lines. Remember the camera crew that was insistently sent along with the NSG in Mumbai at Nariman House? Yes, all the Indian media is capable of doing is fucking things up. All this in the name of bravery.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. A nice attempt – but for an overdose of sarcasm and passion – which essentially echoes the majority view on the subject. A word of unsolicited advise, though. Views on all contentious issues, if communicated without using bad words, carry a much stronger punch. It is necessary to sound restrained than going over the top and reducing the opinion expressed, to a rant.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Kaka, I appreciate your advice but I’d like to point out here that this is the way I actually speak among my peers. I make it a point to sound as undiplomatic as possible because that’s who I am.

      Like

  3. I agree with Varun. As far as (morale, respect, gratitude, condemn) is concerned, I carry the same sentiments and I guess (hope) lot of people in our country carry the same sentiments. It was evident from the pissed off comments made by many in response to Mahira Khan’s “preaching” Twitter comments.

    Though I would like to differ with you about realising the existing movies. Everyone should contribute on their part. Producers should abstain from releasing the movie and we audience from watching such movies to pay their respect, gratitude. Can we not “sacrifice” one or two movies? That will be shame on us. Of course that’s no contribution, but come on! Not even this?

    As far as loses are concerned, we should leave it to the producers. These are smart businessmen and already have their contingency plan. I guess Red Chillies already postponed the release of Raees to Jan 2017. I hope this was out of respect and not just a contingency plan.

    We audience should send out a message loud and clear. If producers dare to release such movies at such sensitive times, then they are heading for big losses.

    Like someone commented, let them release the movie at a later date, when Pakistan stops promoting terrorism and starts to act reasonably, but definitely not now. Make a movie without these ungrateful actors and we audience will make up for your losses.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Red Chillies had planned to release Raees in Jan ’17 much earlier. ADHM should be pushed but given the closing down of major studios and single-screen theatres, the postponement would mean massive losses for exhibitors. While Dharma and Fox Star can afford to release the film later, the exhibitors, many of them in small towns and selling tickets at relatively cheaper rates than city multiplexes, will have massive problems. That said, there is a lot the glittering stars of ADHM can do for the soldiers, which they should do

      Like

  4. Varun you write well and with passion. Anything done without passion is not worth it I feel. Someone asked me , what do you think of what salmaan said? My reply was, I don’t. Seriously. The government must revoke their work permits, ask them to leave, and welcome them to return when things normalise.
    The thing is these are fine actors, producers, directors, singers. I would pay to watch their work. But I do not have the time or the inclination to think about what they say. Their work should speak their mouths shouldn’t. Thats my take on it. But I am just an intolerant kinda person . I find it difficult to tolerate most humanbeings. Love my dogs much much better.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Absolutely true. And what should we understand when the paki govt bans Indian movies and actors n actresses for the heck of it. Recent example the movie Dhoni. The so called high profile chatter boxes should be sent to live with the Jawans in the actual defence line then may be they might realise . Perfect Varun , words for my feelings too.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s